Department of Defense Clearinghouse Response: DoD Clearinghouse response to a request from the BRAC Commission for a copy of the white paper in minutes from the 12Apr2005 "Military Value Update" Civilian Personnel Offices, "the Chair noted the top two jocations in military value were not chosen as receiving locations and asked the analysts to list talking points with the retionale for the decisions." a) please provide complete list of talking points referred to in the minutes; b} Rock Island Arsenal isprovide complete list of talking points referred to in the minutes; b} Rock Island Arsenal is not closing. CPO is not in leased space. Rock Island was ranked #1 with military value of 0.843. Rock Island capacity analysis shows shortfall of 6%; Aberdeen shortfall is 10%. Please discuss in detail the rationale for relocating Rock Island CPO to Ft Riley and Aberdeen.